November 14, 2026 · Supreme Court of Ohio
Hilton v. Lorain, 2026-Ohio-4114
A trial court that finds one or more Civ.R. 23 requirements unmet may still decide whether the remaining requirements are satisfied, and doing so is a rigorous analysis, not a contradiction, even without an express statement that it is assuming the failed requirements for the sake of argument. The Supreme Court reversed the Ninth District and remanded for that court to decide the plaintiffs' remaining assignments of error; it did not rule on whether certification was properly denied.
November 6, 2026 · Supreme Court of Ohio
Estate of Price v. Kidney Care Specialists, L.L.C., 2026-Ohio-4270
A for-cause challenge under R.C. 2313.17(B)(9) is a principal challenge: if the trial court finds it valid, the juror must be excused, and the court of appeals reviews the trial court's validity determination for competent, credible evidence rather than abuse of discretion. Berk and Hall are overruled to the extent they held otherwise, but the plaintiff still lost because the record supported the trial court's findings that the four challenges were not valid.
October 31, 2026 · Supreme Court of Ohio
A.A. v. S.P., 2026-Ohio-4205
A party who appeals a civil protection order without first filing the objections Civ.R. 65.1(G) requires does not lose appellate jurisdiction, but forfeits review of the alleged errors that could have been raised by objection, and plain-error review is not available as a substitute. Here, that meant no jurisdictional dismissal, but an affirmance of the protection order.