Appellate Ohio

The specialist

Technology does the heavy lifting.
A specialist checks the work.

AThe certified specialist

Every brief is reviewed for accuracy before delivery by an Ohio attorney certified as a specialist in appellate law by the Ohio State Bar Association. Board certification in appellate law is held by only a small fraction of Ohio's lawyers; it requires substantial appellate experience, peer review, and a written examination, and it is the credential Ohio's own rules treat as the gold standard for holding oneself out as a specialist.

We publish the credential rather than a personality. The reviewing specialist's identity and certification are disclosed to referring counsel at engagement, where they can be verified directly. Behind the review sits a proprietary, full-text research database of Ohio appellate decisions that powers both our research and our analytics products, and our weekly opinion analysis.

BHow the craft and the technology fit together

We are candid about our method, because it is a feature. Modern research technology reads an enormous volume of authority quickly, drafts capably, and never gets tired. It also, used carelessly, fabricates citations; courts have sanctioned lawyers for exactly that. Our production process is designed around that failure mode:

  • Research begins and ends inside a verified corpus of actual Ohio appellate decisions.
  • A lawyer verifies that each citation is accurate against the official opinion.
  • Every brief ships with a citation verification report your firm can audit in minutes.
  • The certified specialist reviews the finished brief for accuracy.

The result is a thoroughly researched brief, checked for accuracy, at a price a flat fee can cover.

CWhat we know before we write

Our research database holds the full text of more than 53,000 Ohio appellate decisions issued since 2015, from the Supreme Court of Ohio and all twelve district courts of appeals, and it grows every business day. We do not just store those opinions; we read them for what a brief writer needs to know: who sat on the panel, who wrote, who dissented, what kind of case it was, how it arrived, who argued it, and what the court did with the judgment below.

That record produces a working profile of more than 150 Ohio appellate judges: how each one reasons, how often each one reverses and in which kinds of cases, what tends to drive a reversal, and when each one writes separately. When your panel is known, we know how those judges have decided cases like yours. We also measure how long each court takes to rule once a case is argued or submitted. The result is a forecast of the likely outcome and the likely wait, a brief written for the three judges who will actually read it, and a timeline you can give your client with a straight face. A forecast is not a promise, and we never sell it as one. It is a far better place to start than instinct.

DGetting the Supreme Court of Ohio to take the case

A jurisdictional memorandum is the hardest sell in Ohio appellate practice. The Supreme Court of Ohio declines the overwhelming majority of discretionary appeals; in civil cases, it accepts well under one in ten. We track jurisdictional filings as they reach the Court's docket (more than 6,900 since 2020, carrying more than 14,000 propositions of law), and we have studied the full text of more than a thousand memoranda in support of jurisdiction, accepted and declined, together with the memoranda filed against them. From that study we built a scoring model that measures a civil memorandum against the characteristics that separate the cases the Court takes from the cases it turns away.

The model works for you at three points. Before you commit the client's money, we tell you whether the case is a realistic candidate. Before you file, we score the draft, tell you candidly where it stands against the field, and rework the propositions of law and the framing toward what the Court has shown it will accept; or we draft the memorandum from the first page with those characteristics built in. And if you are the appellee, we score the memorandum filed against you, so you know how seriously to take it. We also keep ourselves honest: we score pending memoranda before the Court rules, lock the score, and grade our forecasts against what the Court actually does.

EA note on the word “expert”

Lawyers are rightly careful about claiming expertise. Under Ohio Prof.Cond.R. 7.4(e), a lawyer may state or imply specialization only if the lawyer has been certified as a specialist and the communication clearly identifies the certifying organization. In Peel v. Attorney Registration & Disciplinary Commission of Illinois, 496 U.S. 91 (1990), the United States Supreme Court rejected a categorical ban on a lawyer's truthful, nonmisleading statement of certification as a specialist. We use the word because, here, it is simply accurate and verifiable.

The clock is running: the App.R. 4 deadline is often just 30 days

Send the caption today.
A firm quote within one business day.

Refer an Appeal →